Finished the game yesterday. Quick impressions.
Story - 7 - Had pacing issues, there was a major breakthrough moment in the story about 70% into completion, but the execution fell short. The boss fights were very underwhelming.
Graphics - 9 - NYC looked beautiful, and the game felt generally quite polished when roaming around. Assassin's Creed should take notice.
Gameplay - 8 - Generally very good. Combat was satisfying, but not Batman level of satisfaction.. they borrowed a lot of gameplay elements from the Batman series but added their own twist and it works. It was a lot of fun to play and even web swinging around the city was pure joy.
Overall - 8 - A solid Spiderman game, all in all. With better story pacing and better boss fights the sequel would be a serious contender for GoTY.
PS. Insomniac needs to fire whoever designed and came up with ideas for Spidersuits. Most of the suits,visually speaking, are puke worthy,.