Do we have power problems? Not really (but that also happens), but do we have internet connections issues and limited broadband or "reliable" connection availability? HELL YEAH!
I'm aware of ISP imposed bandwidth limitations in the US, but this isn't really an issue. XBL isn't going to drain your internet bandwidth with its verification checks, unless you plan on playing online or downloading content from the Live Marketplace.
Internet reliability isn't 100% guaranteed anywhere in the world, but is it really a frequently occurring issue for you? I may not be informed enough regarding such problems in the US, but I do know people who run Folding@Home on their PCs 24/7 and are very satisfied with their internet in general. And this may come as a shock to you, but the last unscheduled internet down time I experienced here in Pak was nearly 2 years ago (non-PTCL ISP).
Once again, I'm not indirectly implying that I'm welcoming this 'always-online' approach. However, it will most certainly not come in the way of my decision to buy the new Xbox. There are several factors for me to consider, but this will hold the least significance.
Besides, we don't really know in what capacity this 'always-online' functionality will even be implemented. Maybe the console only needs to perform a one-time verification check at startup or every time you boot a disc.
People who've owned games on Steam already know what it's like to need an internet connection at startup, and I've hardly seen anyone complaining on that front.
Also, people in Pakistan better pray that these rumors don't come to fruition. I KNOW for a fact that they rely heavily on pirated and used games. An always-online console means the death of that console in Pakistan. Not that MS or Sony'd care about that but yeah, it'll be a big set back to Pakistani gamers.
My guess is that the always-online policy will only be imposed on consoles sold via subscription (at a $99 or so starting price). That way, MS can easily disable a box if someone refuses to pay according to the subscription plan. Anyone who pays the full price upfront and gets the console will probably not have to go through with any restriction. But this is just speculation on my part.