Hostel isn't a horror movie. It's a slasher (sub-genre). It's a pity though, that you don't like slow-horror movies
I love slow building horror XD And IMO going too fast sometimes ruins alot of scarefactor. And I liked The Village. Much more than The Grudge, and God forbid, The Cave and Descent.
On that note, I'd point out you should watch 'Descent'. I get a feeling you will like it. It's about 6 women, one of whom has a disturbing past, going on an abventure in some caverns to find out it's filled to brim with pale-green eyed humanoid creatures. It has alot of blood (some on which was really pointless) and lots and lots of gore for you. And oh! A particular (porn) scene with one of the protagonists and the creatures XD I was laughing stock at that lol (just kidding).
There's Venom, I Know What You Did Last Summer, Darkness Falls, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Jeapers Creepers 1 & 2, Fear Dot Com (this movie gave me such a good sleep, The Exorcism Of Emily Rose (this one
might bore you though), The Exorcist, Silent Hill (this one isn't really scary, it's depressing. But it gave me Pyramid Head nightmares!), Creep, The Ring/The Ring two (MAYBE), Dark Water (this is one is my personal favourite, but I don't think you'll like it much), Blair Witch Project, Freaky Friday, Saw trilogy, The Sixth Sense (sloooow), and maybe The Fog.
Note: The movies listed above are not my favourites, with the exception of Emily Rose, The Sisth Sense, Dark Water, Silent Hill, and The Ring (NOT TWO!)